Antibody tests: IgM and IgG

What a positive result means, and why IgM misleads so often.

An antibody test (called serology) doesn't look for the germ. It looks for your immune system's record of meeting it. That makes it powerful for telling you about the past, and much less reliable about the present.

A typical pattern with an arbitrary scale, and every infection differs. The dotted line is the lab's cut-off. Move through time to see what each test would report.

IgM and IgG, as a rule of thumb

Result Usual meaning
IgM negative, IgG negative Never exposed, or it's too early. Someone who can't make antibody, on rituximab for instance, can also test negative, so they'd need PCR.
IgM positive, IgG negative Very recent, or a false positive
IgM positive, IgG positive Recent, or sometimes a reactivation, or a false positive
IgM negative, IgG positive Past infection or vaccination, or antibody received from immunoglobulin, blood products or, in babies, the mother

Why IgM misleads so often

The textbook story is that IgM means "recent". Real IgM tests often break that rule, for several reasons.

So an isolated, weakly positive IgM on its own is often not evidence of a current infection, particularly with no matching symptoms and a negative PCR.

Doctors usually confirm with a second method, a repeat test two to four weeks later, or avidity testing. Avidity is the strength of IgG's grip. High avidity argues against an infection in the last few months, while low avidity suggests a recent one but isn't proof. A fourfold rise in titre between two samples is good evidence of active infection, which for a virus that stays may be a reactivation.

Antibody test or PCR?

PCR Antibody test
Looks for The germ's genetic material Your response to it
Good at Current infection, from the right sample Past exposure, immunity, or a recent infection with a clear pattern
Window From early on Usually negative for 1 to 2 weeks or so
Limitation Timing and site matter, and it can pick up harmless shedding Doesn't tell you if the germ is active

Epstein-Barr virus

EBV has its own set of antibody tests and is one of the clearer patterns.

What's positive Usual meaning
Nothing Never infected
VCA IgM and VCA IgG Current or recent glandular fever
VCA IgG and EBNA IgG Past infection, as in most adults
VCA IgM only Very early infection or a false positive, so repeat in 2 to 4 weeks
VCA IgG only Probably past infection, as some people lose or never make EBNA IgG, or possibly recent
All three Usually past infection, with lingering or falsely positive IgM, or late in a recent infection

EBNA IgG takes weeks to months to appear, so its presence argues against an infection in the last few weeks. High EBV antibody levels in an otherwise well person tell you little, because levels vary widely between people, and shouldn't be taken as "chronic EBV". Chronic active EBV disease is a real but rare and serious illness, diagnosed with very high viral levels and tissue involvement.

Herpes simplex

Test What to know
PCR swab from a sore The best test while a sore is present. It's the most sensitive method, and tells HSV-1 from HSV-2.
Type-specific IgG Tells you if you've been infected at some time, but not when. HSV-2 antibody almost always means genital infection, while HSV-1 antibody can't tell oral from genital. Can take up to about 3 months to turn positive.
IgM Not recommended. It doesn't reliably tell a new from an old infection, and major guidelines, including from the US CDC, advise against it.

Low-positive results on common IgG tests can be false positives, particularly with HSV-2, and confirmation may be needed.

How to read any antibody result

Ask four questions.

  1. How likely was this before the test? In a person with no matching symptoms or exposure, even a good test gives many false positives.
  2. Which antibody? IgM and IgG mean very different things, and so do different targets.
  3. How high? A weak positive close to the cut-off is much less reliable than a strong one.
  4. Does it fit? Symptoms, timing, and other tests, including PCR, matter more than one value.

Antibody tests tell you about your immune system's history. IgG usually means past exposure, and an isolated IgM is often misleading, so it needs a second test or a repeat before you believe it.

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload ๐Ÿ—™