Vaccines

The kinds, why some need boosters, and the maths of herd immunity.

A vaccine shows the adaptive immune system a target along with enough of a danger signal, so that memory forms without the illness. It's the most effective thing the immune system has ever been asked to do.

The kinds

Type What's in it Examples Notes
Live weakened A weakened germ that doesn't cause disease in a healthy person, but can in someone with weak immunity MMR, chickenpox, BCG, yellow fever The strongest, longest memory. Generally not for people who are immune-suppressed or pregnant.
Inactivated A killed germ Most flu shots, polio injection, hepatitis A Safe with low immunity, needs boosters
Protein subunit Just one or a few pieces Hepatitis B, HPV, whooping cough, shingles Precise, needs an adjuvant
Toxoid An inactivated toxin Tetanus, diphtheria Protects against the toxin itself
Conjugate Sugar capsule joined to a protein Pneumococcal, Hib, meningococcal Gets T cells to help, so it works in babies
mRNA Instructions for your cells to make a viral protein COVID-19, RSV Fast to design, and the fatty coating acts as adjuvant
Viral vector A harmless virus delivers the gene Ebola, some COVID-19 Strong T cell responses

Adjuvants: the danger signal

A pure protein on its own gives a weak response, because dendritic cells don't sense any danger. Adjuvants supply it. Alum has been used since the 1920s, and AS01, a combination of a bacterial lipid and a plant extract, is what makes the shingles vaccine work so well in older people.

The sore arm, the tiredness and the low fever the next day are mostly this innate response doing what it's supposed to do. They don't mean you've caught anything, and people without much in the way of side effects still get protected.

Why boosters

The first dose starts germinal centres working. The second, a few weeks or months later, brings memory cells back, yielding more cells and better antibody. How often you need more depends on how fast antibody falls and whether the germ changes.

Pattern Examples
Often once or twice is enough for life Measles, yellow fever
Long gaps Tetanus, about every 10 years, sooner after a dirty or deep wound if the last dose was over 5 years ago
Changes every year Flu
Mucosal infection, so blood antibody only does so much COVID-19, whooping cough. Protection against severe disease lasts much longer than protection against any infection at all.

Herd immunity

If enough people are immune, an infected person meets too few who can catch it, and the outbreak dies out. Everyone benefits, including those who can't be vaccinated.

The maths is short. If one case infects R₀ others in an unprotected population, the outbreak shrinks once the immune share passes 1 − 1/R₀.

Each dot is a person, and everyone has an equal chance of meeting anyone, which is the simplest assumption. Real outbreaks cluster, so pockets with low coverage can still burn.

Measles spreads to about 12 to 18 others, so 92 to 95% of people need to be immune. It comes back quickly when coverage slips. Flu spreads to about 1 to 2 people, but it changes and the vaccine's effect is partial, so herd immunity doesn't really apply.

Safety

Vaccines are monitored more closely than almost any other drug, across billions of doses. Serious side effects are real and rare: anaphylaxis at about 1 in a million doses, myocarditis in young men after some mRNA COVID-19 doses, and rare clotting with viral-vector COVID-19 vaccines. These are far outweighed by the disease risk in most groups, although that balance does depend on the person. The claim that MMR causes autism has been tested in millions of children and doesn't hold up, and the original paper was retracted and its author struck off.

Inactivated and protein vaccines are worth planning around immune-suppressing treatment, because they work better given before it starts. Live vaccines generally need to go in at least 4 weeks before immune suppression starts, and need checking with a doctor once you're on it.

A vaccine is a target plus a danger signal. Boosters refine and renew the response, and above a certain immune share, outbreaks stop on their own.

Sources and further reading

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙