Newton's boldest claim was that the force pulling an apple to the ground is the same force that holds the Moon in its orbit. One short law covers both. Put it into \(F = ma\), and the paths of planets, moons and spacecraft come out.
- Press "A circle". Then drag the arrow's tip a little longer and let go: the orbit becomes an ellipse that swings further out. Make it a little shorter than the circle's, and the ellipse dips inside instead.
- Keep lengthening the arrow. As its tip nears the blue ring, the escape speed, the ellipse stretches without limit. Beyond the ring, the planet never comes back.
- Watch the two arrows on the planet as it flies. Blue is gravity's pull and amber is its velocity. Far out, the pull is weak and the planet crawls. Close in, the pull is strong and it whips round.
- Make the arrow very short, or aim it at the star.
- Turn on the swept areas with an ellipse. Every wedge takes the same time. They're short and fat near the star, long and thin far from it, and the readout measures them as equal.
- Drag the white launch point out to 2 AU and press "A circle". It needs less speed out there, 21.1 km/s, and a lap takes 2.83 years.
The law
Every mass pulls on every other. For two masses \(M\) and \(m\) whose centres are a distance \(r\) apart:
\(G\) is \(6.674 \times 10^{-11}\) N·m²/kg², tiny, which is why you need something the size of a planet to notice the pull. The force points along the line between the two. And it's an inverse-square law: twice as far away, a quarter of the pull. A ball-shaped planet pulls as if all its mass were at its centre.
That gives \(g\) straight away. At the Earth's surface you're one Earth radius, \(6.37 \times 10^6\) m, from the centre of \(5.97 \times 10^{24}\) kg. Multiply that mass by \(G\) and you get \(GM = 3.98 \times 10^{14}\) m³/s², a number worth keeping. Then divide the force on you by your own mass:
A circular orbit
Something in orbit is falling the whole time. It's also moving sideways so fast that it keeps missing. To find the speed that takes, you first need the acceleration of something moving in a circle.
Put the planet on a circle of radius \(r\), going round at a steady \(\omega\) radians a second.
Differentiate twice to get the acceleration. The chain rule brings out an \(\omega\) each time.
That's the position multiplied by \(-\omega^2\). So the acceleration points straight back at the centre, with size \(\omega^2 r\). The speed is \(v = \omega r\), which gives it in terms of speed.
Gravity is the only force, so Newton's second law reads:
The planet's mass cancels. One power of \(r\) does too.
One lap is \(2\pi r\) at that speed. Square it to clear the root, and this is Kepler's third law.
Further out means slower as well as further to go. For anything orbiting the Sun, measuring \(T\) in years and \(r\) in AU makes the constant 1, so \(T^2 = r^3\). That's the figure's 2.83 years at 2 AU: \(\sqrt{2^3} = 2.83\).
Energy and escape
Near the ground, potential energy is \(mgh\). That assumed the pull stays the same as you climb, which fails once you go far enough. To do it properly, find the work it takes to drag the planet from \(r\) out to somewhere very far away:
It's finite, even though the journey isn't. Count the potential energy as zero far away. Then at distance \(r\) the planet is short of that by the work it would take to get out:
The total energy, kinetic plus potential, stays the same all the way round an orbit, and its sign decides the planet's fate.
If \(E\) is negative, the planet can't reach "very far away", where it would need at least zero. It's bound to the star and has to come back. If \(E\) is zero or more, it leaves for good. The escape speed is the speed at which \(E\) is exactly zero, and it's \(\sqrt{2}\) times the circular speed at the same place, about 41% more. Those are the two rings round the launch point.
What makes an ellipse
Launch sideways at exactly the circular speed, and gravity bends the path just as fast as the circle curves. Launch faster, and gravity can't bend it enough. The planet climbs away and slows, trading kinetic energy for potential. Eventually it's too slow for where it is, falls back, picks all the speed up again, and arrives exactly where it started. The closed path is an ellipse with the star at one focus, off-centre. That's Kepler's first law.
Proving it's an ellipse takes the methods of the differential equations chapter. The planet in the figure doesn't use the proof. It knows only that it accelerates towards the star at \(\frac{GM}{r^2}\), and applies that a small step at a time: a little velocity added, then a little distance moved, over and over. The ellipse is what comes out. The dashed outline is what the proof predicts, drawn in advance so you can watch the stepped planet stay on it.
An ellipse's size is set by its energy alone. If \(a\) is half its long axis (a length here, not the acceleration from earlier), then \(E = -\frac{GMm}{2a}\), and Kepler's third law holds with \(a\) in place of \(r\).
Equal areas
Gravity pulls the planet straight along the line to the star, so it has no torque about the star, and the planet's angular momentum can't change. That's Kepler's second law in disguise. In a short time the line to the planet sweeps a thin triangle, with the distance \(r\) as its base and the sideways distance travelled as its height. So the area swept each second is half of \(r\) times the sideways speed, which is the angular momentum divided by \(2m\): for one planet \(I = mr^2\) and \(\omega\) is the sideways speed divided by \(r\), so \(L = I\omega = m r \times\) sideways speed. It never changes, so the planet has to move fastest where it's closest. It's the skater pulling in her arms.
Run this lesson's derivation on the stars at the edges of galaxies and it gives the wrong answer: they orbit much too fast for the mass that can be seen. Vera Rubin's measurements in the 1970s made that hard to argue with, and it's one of the main reasons to think there is dark matter. And the pull between an electron and a proton follows the same inverse-square pattern, so the hydrogen atom starts from the same energy, \(\frac{1}{2}mv^2\) minus a constant over \(r\), with "bound" meaning negative there too.
Problems
The International Space Station orbits about 400 km above the ground, so \(r = 6.77 \times 10^6\) m. For the Earth, \(GM = 3.98 \times 10^{14}\) m³/s². How fast is it going, and how long does a lap take?
Answer
\(v = \sqrt{\frac{3.98 \times 10^{14}}{6.77 \times 10^6}} \approx 7{,}670\) m/s, or 7.67 km/s. One lap is \(2\pi r \approx 4.25 \times 10^7\) m, so \(T = \frac{2\pi r}{v} \approx 5{,}540\) s, about 92 minutes.
This was Newton's own test. The Moon is \(3.84 \times 10^8\) m away, which is 60 Earth radii, and goes round once in 27.3 days. Find its acceleration towards the Earth from \(\frac{v^2}{r}\). Then find what an inverse-square law predicts, starting from 9.81 m/s² at the Earth's surface.
Answer
A lap is \(2\pi \times 3.84 \times 10^8 \approx 2.41 \times 10^9\) m, in \(27.3 \times 86{,}400 \approx 2.36 \times 10^6\) s, so \(v \approx 1{,}020\) m/s and \(\frac{v^2}{r} \approx 0.0027\) m/s². The prediction: 60 times further from the centre means \(60^2 = 3{,}600\) times weaker, and \(\frac{9.81}{3600} \approx 0.0027\) m/s². The apple and the Moon obey one law.
What's the escape speed from the Earth's surface? Use \(GM = 3.98 \times 10^{14}\) m³/s² and \(R = 6.37 \times 10^6\) m.
Answer
\(v = \sqrt{\frac{2 \times 3.98 \times 10^{14}}{6.37 \times 10^6}} \approx 11{,}200\) m/s, or 11.2 km/s.
A planet circles a star like the Sun at 1.5 AU. How long is its year, and how fast does it move? The Earth's speed is 29.8 km/s. Check by launching "A circle" from 1.5 AU in the figure.
Answer
\(T = \sqrt{1.5^3} \approx 1.84\) years. Circular speed goes as \(\frac{1}{\sqrt{r}}\), so it's \(\frac{29.8}{\sqrt{1.5}} \approx 24.3\) km/s. Mars is close to this: 1.52 AU, and a year of 1.88 of ours.
A satellite over the equator that takes exactly as long to orbit as the Earth takes to turn, 86,164 s, and goes the same way round, stays above the same spot. How far from the Earth's centre must it be, and how high above the ground?
Answer
Rearrange Kepler's third law: \(r^3 = \frac{GM\,T^2}{4\pi^2} = \frac{3.98 \times 10^{14} \times 86{,}164^2}{4\pi^2} \approx 7.48 \times 10^{22}\) m³, and taking the cube root, \(r \approx 4.214 \times 10^7\) m. That's about 42,100 km from the centre, and with the Earth's radius of 6,370 km taken off, about 35,800 km above the ground.
In the figure, the "An ellipse" launch is sideways at 35.0 km/s from 1 AU, where the circular speed is 29.8 km/s. Use energy to find \(a\), half the ellipse's long axis. Then find how far out the planet gets and how long a lap takes, and check the last two against the readout.
Answer
Set the energy at launch equal to \(-\frac{GMm}{2a}\) and divide through by \(GMm\): \(\frac{v^2}{2GM} - \frac{1}{r} = -\frac{1}{2a}\), so \(\frac{1}{a} = \frac{2}{r} - \frac{v^2}{GM}\). With \(r = 1\) AU, \(GM\) is the circular speed squared, so \(\frac{v^2}{GM} = \left(\frac{35.0}{29.8}\right)^2 \approx 1.38\). Then \(\frac{1}{a} = 2 - 1.38 = 0.62\) and \(a \approx 1.61\) AU. A sideways launch starts at one end of the long axis. The long axis is \(2a \approx 3.2\) AU, and the launch point is 1 AU from the star along it, so the far end is about 2.2 AU out. \(T = \sqrt{1.61^3} \approx 2.04\) years. The figure keeps more decimal places and gives 2.23 AU and 2.05 years.