A collision is over in a few thousandths of a second. The forces during it are huge, brief and impossible to know in detail. You don't need them. One quantity is the same after the collision as before, whatever happened in between, and it's usually enough to tell you how things come out.
- Press Collide. Each row of momentum arrows is laid end to end, A's then B's. Before and after, they finish on the same amber line.
- Slide Bounciness down to "they stick" and collide again. The momentum arrows still end on the line. The energy bar doesn't keep up: part of it has turned red.
- Watch the amber dots under the track. Their spacing never changes, even at the moment of impact. The rows for A and B both kink there.
- Give the carts equal masses, leave B at rest and make it fully elastic. What does A do afterwards?
- Equal masses, sticking, A at 3 m/s and B at −3 m/s. The total momentum is zero. What's left moving?
- Make A 6 kg and B 0.5 kg, with B at rest and fully elastic. B leaves at nearly twice the speed A came in at. Then swap the masses and watch the light one bounce back.
Momentum and impulse
Momentum is mass times velocity. It has a direction, and in one dimension that's its sign.
Newton's second law is a statement about it. Since \(ma = m\frac{dv}{dt} = \frac{d(mv)}{dt}\):
Force is the rate at which momentum changes. Integrate both sides over the time a force acts, and you get how much it changes altogether. That integral is called the impulse: the area under a graph of force against time.
The same change in momentum can come from a large force for a short time or a small force for a long one. That's the main job of an airbag. Your momentum has to go to zero either way. The bag makes the stop take many times longer than a steering wheel would, so the force is that many times smaller.
Why the total never changes
While the carts touch, A pushes on B with some force that changes from instant to instant. By Newton's third law, B pushes back on A exactly as hard, the other way.
They touch each other for exactly the same time, so the two impulses are equal and opposite too.
Each impulse is a change in momentum.
Whatever one cart gains, the other loses. The total is the same afterwards as before.
Here \(u\) is a velocity before the collision and \(v\) the same cart's velocity after it. Notice what the argument didn't need: the size of the force, how long it lasted, or whether the carts bounced, crumpled or stuck. It only needs nothing from outside to be pushing along the track while they collide.
Elastic or not
Conservation of momentum is one equation, and there are two speeds to find. The second fact is how bouncy the collision is.
- They stick. Then there's only one speed afterwards, and momentum gives it: \(v = \frac{m_A u_A + m_B u_B}{m_A + m_B}\). This loses as much kinetic energy as a collision can.
- Elastic. Kinetic energy is conserved as well. In one dimension that turns out to mean something simple: the carts part exactly as fast as they came together, \(v_B - v_A = u_A - u_B\). Problem 6 shows why.
- In between. They part at some fraction of the speed they closed at. That fraction is the figure's Bounciness.
The energy that goes missing isn't destroyed. It has become heat, sound and bent metal. Kinetic energy can leak away like that and momentum can't, because of what heat is: the atoms' own jiggling, in every direction at once. Their energies add up, but their momenta point every way and cancel. Energy can hide in heat. Momentum has nowhere to hide.
The centre of mass
The centre of mass is the balance point of the two carts, the average of their positions weighted by mass. Differentiate it to get its velocity.
The top of that second fraction is the total momentum, so \(v_{\text{cm}}\) is the total momentum divided by the total mass. The total momentum doesn't change in the collision, so neither does \(v_{\text{cm}}\). However violent things get, the centre of mass glides through at a steady speed, as the amber dots show. When the carts stick, they both end up travelling with it.
Conservation of momentum runs deeper than Newton's laws and outlives them. It holds in relativity and in quantum mechanics, where force stops being a useful idea. By 1930 it was clear that energy seemed to go missing in one kind of radioactive decay, and Wolfgang Pauli proposed an unseen particle carrying it off: the neutrino, finally detected in 1956. Experiments at CERN still find invisible particles the same way. They add up the momentum of everything that leaves a collision and look for what's missing. The underlying reason, shown by Emmy Noether in 1918, is a symmetry: momentum is conserved because the laws of physics are the same here as they are a metre to the left.
Problems
A 0.16 kg cricket ball is bowled at 40 m/s. What's its momentum?
Answer
\(p = mv = 0.16 \times 40 = 6.4\) kg·m/s.
The batter hits it straight back at 30 m/s. The bat touches the ball for 0.0012 s. What's the average force on the ball?
Answer
Take the way it came as negative. Its velocity goes from −40 to +30 m/s, a change of 70 m/s, so \(\Delta p = 0.16 \times 70 = 11.2\) kg·m/s. Then the average force is \(\frac{11.2}{0.0012} \approx 9{,}300\) N, about the weight of a small car.
A 1,500 kg car travelling at 20 m/s runs into the back of a stationary 1,000 kg car, and they lock together. How fast do they move off? How much kinetic energy was lost?
Answer
Momentum before is \(1500 \times 20 = 30{,}000\) kg·m/s, shared afterwards by 2,500 kg: \(v = 12\) m/s. Kinetic energy before is \(\frac{1}{2} \times 1500 \times 20^2 = 300{,}000\) J, and after it's \(\frac{1}{2} \times 2500 \times 12^2 = 180{,}000\) J. So 120,000 J, 40% of it, went into crumpling the cars.
In the figure's first setting, a 2 kg cart at 3 m/s hits a 1 kg cart at rest, fully elastic. Find both velocities afterwards, and check that the kinetic energy is the same before and after. Then check against the figure.
Answer
Momentum: \(2v_A + v_B = 6\). Elastic, so they part as fast as they closed: \(v_B - v_A = 3\). Put \(v_B = v_A + 3\) into the first: \(3v_A + 3 = 6\), so \(v_A = 1\) m/s and \(v_B = 4\) m/s. Energy before: \(\frac{1}{2} \times 2 \times 3^2 = 9\) J. After: \(\frac{1}{2} \times 2 \times 1^2 + \frac{1}{2} \times 1 \times 4^2 = 1 + 8 = 9\) J.
Two skaters stand still on ice, facing each other: one of 60 kg, one of 40 kg. They push off against each other, and the 60 kg skater glides away at 2 m/s. How fast does the other one go? Where is their centre of mass a few seconds later?
Answer
The total momentum was zero and still is: \(60 \times 2 + 40 \times v = 0\), so \(v = -3\) m/s, the opposite way. The centre of mass was at rest and nothing outside pushed on them, so it's exactly where it started.
Show that when both momentum and kinetic energy are conserved, the carts part as fast as they came together: \(v_B - v_A = u_A - u_B\).
Answer
Put each cart's terms on one side. Momentum: \(m_A(u_A - v_A) = m_B(v_B - u_B)\). Energy, with the halves cancelled: \(m_A(u_A^2 - v_A^2) = m_B(v_B^2 - u_B^2)\). Each side of the energy equation is a difference of two squares, and \(a^2 - b^2 = (a - b)(a + b)\): \(m_A(u_A - v_A)(u_A + v_A) = m_B(v_B - u_B)(v_B + u_B)\). Divide by the momentum equation, which is allowed because the speeds did change, and the masses go: \(u_A + v_A = v_B + u_B\), which rearranges to \(v_B - v_A = u_A - u_B\).