Autoimmunity

When tolerance fails, why it fails, and how early it starts.

8. When it goes wrong About 4 min read

Autoimmune disease happens when the system meant to hold back self-reactive cells fails. These conditions are common: a study of 22 million people in the UK found 10.2% had at least one of the 19 most common, 13.1% of women and 7.4% of men, and rates were rising.

What it looks like

Disease What's attacked Main driver
Type 1 diabetes Insulin-making cells in the pancreas Killer T cells
Rheumatoid arthritis Joint lining T cells, B cells, TNF and IL-6
Multiple sclerosis Myelin in the brain and spinal cord T cells and B cells
Hashimoto's thyroiditis Thyroid, which gets underactive T cells and antibodies
Graves' disease Thyroid, driven to be overactive An antibody that imitates a hormone
Myasthenia gravis Nerve-muscle junction Antibodies against a receptor
Coeliac disease Small bowel lining, set off by gluten T cells and IgA
Lupus (SLE) Many organs: DNA and nuclear proteins Antibodies, immune complexes, interferon
Psoriasis Skin IL-23 and IL-17

Why it happens

No single cause is known for most of these. The usual picture is genes plus trigger plus chance.

Genes. Often HLA, and several genes that adjust immune signalling. An identical twin of someone with an autoimmune disease has a much higher risk but often doesn't get it, typically 20 to 50%, so genes aren't the whole story.

Triggers. Infection, smoking (particularly for rheumatoid arthritis and MS), some drugs, sun exposure (lupus), gluten (coeliac), low vitamin D (possibly MS).

Being female. Lupus and Sjögren's are about nine times as common in women, for reasons including hormones and genes on the X chromosome.

How infections can start it

Mechanism What it means Example
Molecular mimicry A pathogen's protein looks like one of yours, so the antibody or T cell hits both Rheumatic fever after Streptococcus; in some people with MS, an antibody to an EBV protein that also grips a brain protein
Bystander activation Inflammation wakes self-reactive cells that happen to be nearby Viral infections and flares in general
Exposure of hidden targets Damage releases self proteins not normally seen Injury to one eye, sometimes affecting the other
Epitope spreading The response gradually widens to new targets Lupus, MS

The first of these, molecular mimicry, is the easiest to picture.

Slide the two proteins closer together and watch where the antibody goes, or start a new infection to see it from the beginning. A cartoon of one mechanism, not to scale: likeness is a single made-up number, the time axis has no units, and T cells can cross-react in the same way as antibody. The lupus figure in the readout is about silent phases in general, not about mimicry.

It starts long before symptoms

A remarkable study used stored blood from US service members. In lupus, 88% of those who later got the diagnosis had at least one autoantibody before diagnosis, up to 9.4 years early and 3.3 years on average. Rheumatoid arthritis and type 1 diabetes show the same pattern. So autoimmunity commonly goes through a silent phase, which may one day allow for prevention. In type 1 diabetes, the drug teplizumab can already delay onset in high-risk people.

Autoantibodies aren't always disease

Plenty of healthy people have autoantibodies, particularly with age. ANA at low levels is found in as many as a fifth or more of healthy people, depending on how it's measured. So a positive result only means something in combination with symptoms and findings. See Reading immune blood tests.

These diseases often cluster, in individuals and in families. Thyroid disease, coeliac and type 1 diabetes particularly go together. Fatigue is also common across autoimmune conditions, often out of proportion to measurable inflammation, and its causes aren't well understood. Treatment has moved towards drugs that target single signals.

Autoimmunity is about one person in ten, usually from a mix of genes, a trigger and chance. It often begins silently, years before symptoms appear.

Sources and further reading

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙