Too much, for too long

Sepsis, cytokine storms, smouldering inflammation and the brakes that fail.

8. When it goes wrong About 4 min read

Inflammation amplifies itself: TNF and IL-1 bring in cells that make more TNF and IL-1. That's why it's quick. But a self-feeding loop needs a strong brake and a clear end point, and when these fail, the response itself becomes the disease.

A toy model with three equations, to show the logic and not any specific disease. The self-feeding has a tipping point: past it, inflammation carries on with no germ left. The picture shows the day marked on the graph, which you can drag, and each slider thickens one arrow of the loop. The cells are a cartoon of the model's three numbers, not to scale.

What the model shows

Below the tipping point, inflammation rises with the germ and falls after it. That's normal healing.

At the tipping point, the loop no longer needs the germ. It's a real feature of many self-amplifying systems with a brake. Once it's past that point, removing the original cause isn't enough, and that's one way of thinking about why some inflammatory conditions continue after their trigger has gone.

Far past it, it runs high and fast, and the tissue damage (the red line) becomes the main threat.

Too much, too fast

Sepsis is organ failure caused by a dysregulated response to infection. Vessels leak all over the body, so blood pressure falls. Clotting goes wrong, and organs lose blood supply. It's a major cause of death worldwide. Treatment is antibiotics and support as fast as possible, since blocking single cytokines has largely failed in trials. Some people's immune systems are in fact exhausted, rather than over-active, by the later stages.

Cytokine storm is a loose term for overwhelming cytokine release. It's seen after CAR-T treatment, in severe COVID-19 and in a condition called HLH, in which T cells and macrophages keep activating one another. Some of these respond well to targeted drugs. Tocilizumab, which blocks the IL-6 receptor, works in CAR-T cases. In severe COVID-19, dexamethasone, a cheap steroid, cut deaths among those on oxygen or ventilators.

Too much, for too long

Autoinflammatory diseases come from the innate system, without autoantibodies or matching T cells. Inherited types, like familial Mediterranean fever, cause repeated fevers with nothing to trigger them, usually from mutations in inflammasome genes, and often respond dramatically to blocking IL-1. Gout is a common relative of these.

Chronic low-grade inflammation has several common drivers.

It's measurable as slightly higher CRP and IL-6, and it's linked to heart disease, diabetes and more.

Cause and effect can be hard to separate, but there's a good test of it. In the CANTOS trial of more than 10,000 heart attack survivors, blocking IL-1-beta with canakinumab reduced further cardiovascular events, without lowering cholesterol. That shows that inflammation itself drives heart disease. It also raised the risk of fatal infections, which shows the cost of the trade-off.

Why the brakes fail

"Inflammation" gets blamed for a lot of things online. Real inflammation can be measured, and many sets of vague symptoms come with a normal CRP. Lower background inflammation has good evidence behind it for not smoking, exercise, weight loss if needed and treating gum disease. Anti-inflammatory diets are less well supported.

Inflammation is self-amplifying, so it needs brakes and an end point. Too much too fast means sepsis, and a low level for too long feeds many chronic diseases.

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload ๐Ÿ—™