Pathogens that survive today are the descendants of those that got round immunity. Every defence you've read about has some microbe with a counter to it. It's an arms race going back hundreds of millions of years, and the immune system's own genes are among the fastest-changing in the human genome as a result.
The main strategies
| Strategy | How it works | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Hide | Stay inside cells, turn off genes, or live where immunity is weak | Herpesviruses in nerve cells, TB in macrophages, HIV as DNA in resting T cells |
| Change | Alter the surface so that antibodies no longer fit | Flu's drift and shift, malaria and trypanosome coat-switching, Neisseria gonorrhoeae |
| Disguise | Cover the surface, or look like host cells | Sugar capsules that hide what phagocytes grip, a few copying human sugars; HIV's sugar shield |
| Disable the display | Stop cells from showing what's inside | Herpesviruses and HIV pull MHC class I off the surface |
| Fool the check | Provide a fake version of what NK cells look for | CMV's MHC-like decoy |
| Block the alarm | Cut off interferon signalling inside the cell | Many viruses, including flu and SARS-CoV-2 |
| Disarm complement | Make or borrow proteins that stop the cascade | Herpes simplex, Neisseria, Staphylococcus |
| Grab antibodies backwards | Bind the stem so the arms face out, uselessly | Staph's protein A, HSV's Fc receptor |
| Send the wrong signals | Make copies of human cytokines | EBV's version of IL-10, which calms the immune response |
| Kill the defenders | Attack the immune cells themselves | HIV kills CD4 T cells, measles attacks memory cells, Staph kills neutrophils |
| Overwhelm it | Set off a dangerous overreaction | Superantigens in toxic shock |
The cost of mimicry
When a pathogen looks like you, the immune system may attack you while it's fighting the pathogen.
The classic case is rheumatic fever. Antibodies made against group A Streptococcus throat infections also recognise proteins in the heart valves. This can lead to lasting heart damage, long after the throat has healed, which is one reason sore throats in at-risk communities get antibiotics. See Autoimmunity.
What your genes kept
The arms race has left marks on you.
- About 8% of your genome is made up of old retroviruses. Some of their pieces have been reused, including some that switch interferon genes on, and one that helps build the placenta.
- A 32-base deletion in the gene CCR5, which about 10% of northern Europeans carry one copy of, makes people who have two copies highly resistant to HIV. It's how most of the handful of people cured of HIV by stem cell transplant were cured, though at least two had donors without two copies, so the donor cells clearing the infection must matter too.
- HLA diversity is thought to have been maintained by infection through thousands of generations.
- People carrying one sickle cell gene are protected against malaria, at the cost of the disease in those who inherit two.
This is why new treatments like antivirals and monoclonal antibodies so often stop working. Pathogens are under intense selective pressure. Combining drugs, as in HIV treatment, makes it far harder for a mutant to survive all of them at once.
Every immune weapon has a counter somewhere in the microbial world. Long-term infections tend to be caused by the pathogens with the best tricks.